Sure, you’ve done everything by the book when filing your health insurance claim. You’ve filled out all the forms, itemized every service bill, and even penned a summary letter about your care. But, your insurance company still turned you down, leaving you with a hefty medical bill and no clear way to pay it. But don’t lose hope just yet. Your denial letter isn’t the final word. If you’re determined and file a proper appeal, you might still get your claim paid, at least partially.
Here’s how you can appeal a denied health insurance claim:
-
Understand the Denial Letter: Insurance companies don’t just deny claims without giving a reason. They’ll send you a letter explaining why they denied your claim. Common reasons include billing or coding errors, clerical mistakes by the insurance company, receiving service from an out-of-network provider, incomplete initial claim due to missing or incorrect paperwork, insufficient information for the insurer to make a decision, the service or procedure wasn’t deemed medically necessary, your health insurance plan didn’t cover the service or procedure, or the claim was denied during the pre-authorization process. Review this letter carefully. If it’s not clear, call the insurance company’s claims processing department and ask for a full explanation. If it’s a simple error, they might fix it right away.
-
Collect Supporting Documents: Depending on why your claim was denied, gather the necessary documents to support your claim. This could include a detailed, itemized bill from your hospital or doctor’s office, a letter of medical necessity from your provider’s office, a note from your employer, peer-reviewed studies, a second opinion from another medical provider, or medical records that provide more information about your symptoms and how your condition has changed over time.
-
Keep Detailed Records: Document every interaction with your insurance company, healthcare provider, and anyone else involved in your appeal. This includes the name and title of the person you spoke with, their contact information, what you discussed, and the outcome of the conversation.
-
Write an Appeal Letter: Once you’ve gathered all the necessary documents, write a clear, factual appeal letter. Include the initial claim number, the insurance identification number, the date(s) of medical care, the insured’s name, address, and birthdate. In the first paragraph, state that you want to appeal the denied claim and why. Use the rest of the letter to explain why your appeal is valid, always pointing back to supporting evidence. Avoid emotional language or unnecessary information. End the letter with a clear demand that the insurer accept your claim and pay your medical bills.
-
Wait for the Decision: Don’t expect an immediate response. The insurance company needs time to review your documents and letter and decide whether to reverse the denial. This can take up to 60 days, though many appeals resolve within a few business days.
If your appeal is denied again, you can move to the next step, which is an external appeal or review. This usually involves an independent third party that helps consumers with insurance claims and appeals. Depending on your situation, you can hire an independent claims adjuster or health insurance attorney, file a complaint with your state department of insurance or insurance commissioner, enroll in a nonprofit consumer assistance program for insurance customers, or if you have health insurance through a self-insured employer, file a complaint with the U.S. Department of Labor.
Remember, medical bills can be really expensive. Even a partial reimbursement following a successful appeal can save you hundreds or thousands of dollars. Crafting a health insurance appeal takes time and persistence, but it’s not overly complicated. With the right supporting documents and a strong appeal letter, your insurer might reconsider. If not, it might be time to consider changing your health insurance coverage.
